Ohio Health Insurance Marketplace Plans – Best Rates

The Ohio Health Insurance Exchange offers individuals, business owners and families the opportunity to purchase affordable coverage with the help of a federal tax subsidy and guaranteed-approval of submitted applications. Easily, you can shop for quality Ohio medical benefits at the cheapest available rates, either on or off the Marketplace. There are no exclusions, waiting periods or surcharges for pre-existing conditions. We do the shopping so you save. You can also select non-Obamacare Marketplace options.


In less than a minute, you can easily compare the companies that offer the lowest prices for Open Enrollment Exchange plans. You can not be denied for medical reasons and we will help you with the enrollment process. You don't have to worry about the constant glitches and delays that many persons experience on the .gov website. The application process is now much more streamlined, and typically takes less than 20 minutes. If you are 65 or over, you are eligible for Medicare benefits, and can consider Medigap or Advantage contracts to help pay uncovered expenses. And if your household income is limited, you may be eligible for Medicaid.

Missed Open Enrollment? We'll show you stopgap plans that cover you throughout the year. Many "short-term" options are available from major carriers (UnitedHealthcare, Standard Life, HCC Life, and Medical Mutual generally have the most competitive prices) that can be kept as long as 12 months. Coverage can be approved within 24 hours, and benefits will be effective immediately. However, temporary contracts generally do not pay for pre-existing conditions and are not eligible for instant federal tax credits.

Special Enrollment Periods (SEP) are available at any time if you have lost existing coverage, move to a different area, get divorced, have a child, or have a major household income change. There are also several additional "qualifying life event" situations that will allow you to obtain coverage at any time of the year. When you qualify for an exemption, all Marketplace plans in your area are available, and a federal subsidy will apply if you meet household income guidelines.

 Which Ohio Health Insurance Companies Offer Marketplace Plans?


Participating carriers include Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield, Aetna, Ambetter (From Buckeye Health), Medical Mutual, CareSource, HealthSpan, Humana, Molina, UnitedHealthcare, Paramount, Premier, and SummaCare. Assurant and Celtic previously offered private plans but no longer are active writers in the state. InHealth ceased operations in 2016, after mounting claims far exceeded the amount of needed assets available to pay claims.

Many additional companies offer affordable Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans, including AARP, Equitable, Liberty National, Omaha, Physician's Mutual, State Farm, and USAA. Of course, many of the companies that offer coverage to persons under age 65, also offer Senior plans. "Advantage" contracts are also available, and can also include drug and prescription benefits. Medicare Supplements are a popular option for consumers that need to reduce out-of-pocket expenses, including copays, coinsurance, and Part A and B deductibles.


Premier (located in the Dayton area) offers coverage in Montgomery County and other surrounding areas. Miami Valley Hospital and its affiliates are key components in their servicing area and network. Even nearby counties such as Miami, Warren, Clark, Preble, Butler, and Greene are the home of some Premier providers. Although they have only offered individual coverage since 2014, their prices are extremely attractive in Dayton, Middletown, Kettering, Centerville, Oakwood, Franklin, Huber Heights, Tipp City, Vandalia, and Troy.


Miami Valley Hospital And Premier Healthcare Coverage

Premier Health Partners With Miami Valley Hospital In SW Ohio


Many companies also offer short-term "off-Exchange" plans. These types of policies may NOT include "essential health benefits" and are therefore not be considered qualified options. Thus, you may have to pay an Obamacare tax (2.5% of household income) because you did not purchase the type of medical coverage that is required. Several carriers offer specialized options, including critical-illness and accidental expense contracts, that are designed to reduce the expenses of high deductibles and out-of-pocket costs.


HCC Life and IHC Group also feature temporary plans that are not compliant with ACA regulations, but should be considered if you are not eligible for a special enrollment period. You can choose from a wide range of deductibles ($250 to $10,000) with several coinsurance options. These plans are not long-term solutions, but will prevent a catastrophic claim from taking most of your assets. You can email or call us for additional specific details. Benefits from $250,000 to $2 million are available. NOTE: Temporary plans should never be used to replace qualified benefits.


Off-Marketplace Plans


In some situations, there are affordable policies that can be purchased outside of the Marketplace that meet the "essential health benefits" requirement. Since subsidies will not be payed on these contracts, they are viable choices for families with household incomes that do not receive government financial aid. If you lack physicians or specialists in your area, these policies should also be considered since the number of participating doctors, hospitals, and facilities, may be higher than "on-Marketplace" policies.

For example, if you are single (Age 30 and no dependents) making more than $31,000, there's a very high probability that you don't qualify for a federal subsidy. Also, if your family consists of four persons (Ages 40, 40, 12, and 10), and your total household income is more than $98,000, you probably do not qualify for financial assistance. Therefore, selecting a policy away from the Marketplace will allow you to choose plans that may have larger provider networks. However, specific deductibles, copays, and maximum out-of-pocket costs will not vary from standard policies.


Current Rates


Shown below are sample households illustrating the monthly premium for 10 of the most popular and affordable plan options. Federal subsidies, if applicable, have been applied.


30 year-old living in Cincinnati (Hamilton County) with income of $22,000.


$71 -- Molina Marketplace Bronze

$80 -- Ambetter Essential Care 1

$87 -- Ambetter Essential Care 5

$104 -- Ambetter Balanced Care 2

$108 -- Molina Marketplace Silver

$133 -- Aetna Bronze $15 Copay

$153 -- Humana Silver 3800

$166 -- Molina Marketplace Gold

$200 -- Humana Gold 2250

$201 -- Anthem Silver Pathway X 3000 10


45 year-old couple living in Dayton (Montgomery County) with income of $37,000.


$126 -- Premier Health One Bronze 6850

$139 -- Premier Health One Bronze 6500

$166 -- Molina Marketplace Bronze

$168 -- Ambetter Essential Care 1

$187 -- Ambetter Essential Care 5

$233 -- Ambetter Balanced Care 2

$244 -- Premier Health One Silver 4500/20

$270 -- Molina Marketplace Silver

$331 -- Anthem Silver Pathway X 4250 30

$404 -- Premier Health One Gold 1500


50 year-old couple with two children (Total of four persons) living in Columbus (Franklin County) with income of $55,000.


$148 -- CareSource Just4Me Bronze

$235 -- Aetna Bronze Deductible Only HSA

$302 -- UnitedHealthcare Bronze Compass HSA 5500

$307 -- Anthem Bronze Pathway X 5000 40

$321 -- Aetna Bronze $15 Copay

$337 -- Molina Marketplace Silver

$448 -- UnitedHealthcare Silver Compass HSA 3000

$499 -- Anthem Silver Pathway X 4250 30

$505 -- UnitedHealthcare Silver Compass 2000

$614 -- Molina Marketplace Gold


Which Type Of Coverage Is The Cheapest?


Policies are available in four actuarial "Metal" categories. They are Platinum, Gold, Silver and Bronze. The cheapest policy is the Bronze option since it pays the least out-of-pocket expenses (expected). Unlike the Platinum option that covers 90% of expected expenses, the Bronze plan only covers 60%. The State Department Of Insurance regulates the policies although the Federal Government operates the Exchange (for now). It's possible in the future (perhaps after 2018) we'll run our own program here in the Buckeye state, although tens of millions of extra dollars will be needed.

Bronze deductibles are higher, and if you utilize the prescription benefits, you'll pay more. However, you also pay a lower premium, and that extra savings can be used to offset some of your higher expenses. This option is closely comparable to HDHP plans that have been "grandfathered" for many consumers. Silver plans are the second-least expensive policy and are ideal for Ohioans willing to pay a slightly higher premium to reduce deductibles and copays. Since maximum out-of-pocket expenses (MOP) are less than Bronze-tier contracts, they are better choices when the risk of meeting a deductible is higher.

NOTE: Silver tier contracts are the only policies that offer "cost-sharing," a special feature that lowers your out-of-pocket expenditures (deductibles,coinsurance, and copays) if your income is within specific ranges. Some popular "Silver" plans are listed later. Often, depending on your total household income, Silver-tier options are actually more cost-effective than either Gold or Platinum plans. Deductibles can reduce by thousands of dollars and maximum out-of-pocket costs can reduce from more than $6,000 to less than $1,000. However, if your household income increases the following year, it may impact the amount of "cost-sharing."


Catastrophic Options


A catastrophic plan is offered to consumers that may not be able to afford more expensive policies with the required mandated benefits. If you are under age 30, you can automatically qualify. If you are older than age 30, and there are no "affordable" plans available in your area, you will be able to buy this type of bare minimum coverage. Although the deductible is high ($6,850), the rates are typically cheap. Another method of qualifying is if you can prove "financial hardship." NOTE: These types of contracts are ineligible for subsidies, so if your income is below 400% of the Federal Poverty Level, another tier may be a better option. Also, specialist visits are often subject to a deductible, and not a copay.


Ohio Financial Hardship Exemptions For Healthcare

Bankruptcy Qualifies For A "Financial Hardship" Exemption


The financial hardship exemptions that you are most likely to utilize, include recent death of a family member, bankruptcy filing within the last 180 days, large unpaid medical expenses in the last two years, individual plan was terminated and no other affordable options, and Medicaid ineligibility because of lack of state expansion. A few of the least-likely exemptions you might utilize are if you are homeless, received a shut-off notice from your electric/gas company, and recent victim of domestic violence.


Typically, we recommend a Bronze or Silver-tier option instead, since the coverage is much richer and the premium difference many not be substantial. Popular catastrophic plan options are Medical Mutual "Young Essentials," Humana Basic 6850 (available in Dayton, Cincinnati, and Cleveland areas only), InHealth Catastrophic, SummaCare Value, and Anthem's "Catastrophic Pathway X PPO 6850." Although CareSource offers very attractive rates, their network is limited, and other options are often more suitable.


Future Rates


The Society of Actuaries has predicted that prices will continue to increase. They based this prediction by comparing the current average monthly premium of $223 to the projected premium of $420. Although rates did go up last year (and sharply for many individuals and families), the average increase was actually much lower than anticipated. However, for married persons 55 and over with no children in the household, price increases were the highest. For persons under age 35, prices only increased slightly.

The instant federal tax credit (subsidy) helps many consumers pay some of these increases. There are more than 200 plans offered, so broker and website assistance (which we provide free) is highly recommended. Each year, plans change, and often, you actually may be forced to switch policies because your existing contract no longer meets "Metal" guidelines. That is, the actuarial value (AV) changes and a new tier must be classified. Also, many companies discontinue plans at the end of the calendar year. Thus, you must either choose a similar plan with the same carrier, or pick an option with another company. We help you compare the best options and apply before the Open Enrollment deadline expires.

Also, occasionally, new carriers are approved to begin offering qualified coverage. For example, Premier offers policies in several counties in the Dayton and Cincinnati areas. InHealth offers policies in Columbus and selected other areas. Both companies did not offer private plans prior to the creation of the Exchanges. CareSource previously offered Medicaid coverage, but they have now expanded their portfolio to include Marketplace options. Paramount is also a new carrier that offers in plans in Northwest Ohio.


What Specific Plans Are The Least Expensive?


Listed below are many of the most affordable individual (and family) plans available for single persons or families. It is important to understand that not all plans are offered in all counties, and federal financial subsidies do not apply to "catastrophic" tier contracts. Also, as previously mentioned, catastrophic-tier contracts have unique eligibility requirements.


The "cheapest" option may not be the most cost-effective, depending upon many factors, including medications you take and yearly medical expenses. Please contact us before applying for coverage. We will review and compare the specific benefits and cost of your best options. The enrollment process typically takes only 10-20 minutes.


Catastrophic Tier (Three Office Visits Per Year Allowed With No Deductible)


Humana Basic 6850 -- $25 office visit copay and $6,850 deductible. Only available in Dayton, Cincinnati and Cleveland areas.

InHealth Catastrophic-- $6,850 deductible with 100% coverage for first three office visits. Only offered in specific counties.

Medical Mutual Market Young Adult Essentials -- $40 office visit copay with $6,850 deductible.

Anthem Catastrophic Pathway X 6850 0 -- Very similar to Medical Mutual plan although slightly more expensive.

SummaCare Value -- Same deductible as other plans and first free pcp visits are free. Most expensive of all Catastrophic-tier plans.


Bronze Tier


Premier Health One Bronze 6850 -- Available in Dayton area and surrounding counties (Warren, Greene, and SW Ohio). $6,850 deductible with 100% coverage after deductible is met. $6,500 deductible is also available.

Premier Health One Bronze 6000/40 and 6000/35 -- $6,000 deductible with copays on pcp office visits ($50 for 6000/35 plan and $40 for 6000/35 plan). Coinsurance of 40% and 35% respectively.

Ambetter Essential Care 1 -- $6,800 deductible with no coinsurance.

Ambetter Essential Care 5 -- $6,800 deductible with three free pcp office visits. The slightly higher cost for "Care 5" plan is very cost-effective.

Humana Bronze 6450 Dayton HMOx, Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky HMOx and Cleveland HMOx -- Available in three areas. $6,450 deductible and then 100% coverage.

Aetna Bronze Deductible Only HSA -- One of best HSA options in the state. $6,450 deductible with 0% coinsurance. Large nationwide network.

Molina Marketplace Bronze -- $5,000 deductible.

Anthem Bronze Pathway X 5000 40 -- $6,850 deductible and 40% coinsurance.

Aetna Bronze $15 Copay -- $6,850 deductible but low $15 copay on pcp visits (unlimited). Nice plan for families with several healthy children.

HealthSpan Select Bronze 4500-70 HSA -- Another HSA option with a $4,500 deductible and 30% coinsurance.


Is The Government Paying Part Of My Premium?


Ohio health insurance rates, like other states, will be reduced, if you qualify for the immediate tax credit (subsidy). Here's how it works: Individuals and families that have incomes between 100% and 400% of the Federal Poverty Level (FDL), and who buy an "Exchange" policy are eligible for assistance. Medicare and Medicaid recipients  are not eligible. If you miss Open Enrollment and are not eligible for a special exception, you probably will not be eligible for a subsidy. However, you can buy "short-term" coverage to help cover larger potential medical claims until the next OE period begins.


The tax subsidies will immediately reduce your premium. Unlike a normal credit, you don't have to wait for a refund to use the money. Based on current FDL levels, a 30-year-old (male or female) that makes $50,000 per year, will not receive a subsidy. However, if their income is only $25,000, they will receive approximately $1,700. You will also find that some plans will be free! Larger families with several children may also be eligible for CHIP benefits for their children.


Find Cheapest Ohio Exchange Insurance

Affordable Ohio Health Marketplace Plans Are Available

For a family of four (husband and wife age 40 and two children) with a household income of $60,000, the subsidy will be $3,600, or about $300 per month. For this example, we assumed the family lived in Franklin County. Of course, a "Bronze" plan costs less, but would involve more out-of-pocket risk. Once this family income reaches about $95,000, they are no longer eligible for financial assistance. However, larger families can qualify for subsidies with bigger incomes. Your MAGI (Modified Adjusted Gross Income) is used to determine eligibility.


When And How Do You Apply For A Policy?


Our website has direct links that make it easy for you to apply for coverage. Tax subsidies are automatically calculated so you know how much (if any) of the premium will be paid by the federal government. Open Enrollment begins in November each year and continues for three months. However, as previously mentioned, if you forget to apply for coverage, other options are available, including SEP exceptions and temporary plans.


Although the standard application has various questions, none are related to any medical condition you had in the past or are currently being treated for. The vast majority of questions refer to members of the household and other administrative topics. If you qualify for a federal subsidy, some basic financial questions will be asked about your projected income. We're always available to help you fill out and complete the application. Choosing the most cost-effective plan may also require some assistance.


Can You Buy A Policy That Is Not Through The Exchange?


Yes. The provider list for Exchange plans is limited, compared to plans offered before Obamacare. In some situations, "off-Exchange" plans offer a wider selection of doctors and hospitals, and they may be a better solution for your specific situation. For example, many carriers have limited specialists and medical facilities available for their Marketplace options, but offer broader network coverage for off-Exchange policies. Tip: If the carrier network has an "X" in the name, often that signifies it is an "on-Exchange" policy.


Prices for all plans are typically released in the late summer for the following calendar year. However, once released, the rates are guaranteed and can not increase until the next Open Enrollment begins. And occasionally, prices remain very stable, or slightly reduce. The State DOI receives filings from companies requesting rate changes, and determines how much (if any) of the proposed changes will be accepted.


Are Rates The Same In All Areas Of The State?


The cost of healthcare in Ohio is different, depending upon which county you reside in. For example, prices in and around Columbus are typically less expensive than prices in Cleveland.  Cincinnati pricing is different than Athens. Toledo, or Canton. It may not necessarily be as substantial as it once was, but there is still a variance. Typically, cities in the Northern counties are the most expensive. The least expensive areas are the counties surrounding Dayton, Columbus, and Cincinnati.


Cheapest Medical Plans Cleveland

Low Cost Cleveland Healthcare Will Be Offered

Naturally, older persons will pay higher premiums and smokers will pay more, unless they quit for at least 12 months. But, as previously discussed, your pre-existing conditions (if applicable) will not impact what you pay. And you can not be denied for a medical issue. Whether you had cancer 10 years ago, or you were just diagnosed with heart disease or diabetes, it will not affect the premium. However, if you miss Open Enrollment, you may be forced to apply for a non-qualified plan, which could require medical questions to be answered. A denial of coverage is also possible.


Are HSA Plans Available?


They are available under "Bronze" and "Silver" tiers, which are the least expensive policy that is offered. These types of plans must meet a "60%" requirement (this means they are expected to pay 60% of the average anticipated medical expenses for an applicant) with a maximum available deductible of $6,550. "Catastrophic" plans may also feature HDHP plans. Periodically, the maximum allowed deductible increases.


HSA plans have historically helped consumers become more cost-conscious with their spending, so their out-of-pocket costs reduce, and a tax-break is included. Coupled with the negotiated pricing that saves money, this type of option is always very popular. Listed below are several popular low-cost HSA plans in the Buckeye State. Not all policies are offered in every county.


UnitedHealthcare Bronze HSA 5000
InHealth Bronze 2 HSA
Anthem Bronze Pathway X PPO 0 HSA
Medical Mutual Market 6000 HSA
HealthSpan Select Bronze 4500-70 HSA
Aetna Broze Deductible Only HSA


Are There Special Plans For Self-Employed Persons?


Although there are not "special" options available, there are many policies that are very suitable if you work for yourself. For example, an HSA (previously mentioned) is designed to keep rates low, reduce your taxes, and allow you to accumulate money in a side-account.  Additional HSA information online  can be found on another page. You can also use these funds to pay for medical, dental, vision or long-term care benefits. Funds not used are never lost. You can allow them to continue to accumulate to be used by yourself or any other family member listed on your policy.


Certainly,  many other plans can be purchased since health insurance rates in Ohio are cheaper than most other states. We're experts on finding the best Marketplace policies for single, family or business situations. Email or call. Instantly, we will review your best options and provide a written copy (sent or emailed).

Ohio Senior Medical Insurance


If you have reached age 65, you are probably eligible for Medicare (not Medicaid!). Although benefits are comprehensive, and most Seniors don't incur high out-of-pocket expenses, Medigap Supplement policies and Advantage plans that replace Medicare, are very popular. They provide affordable options to reduce the cost of deductible, coinsurance, and copays, at a premium that makes financial sense.


We also review and compare Senior policy options and free customized quotes are available by providing your zip code. Unlike private coverage for persons under age 65, enrolling in a supplementary plan is not mandatory, and not necessary if you are satisfied with the basic Medicare benefits that are provided. A separate Open Enrollment period typically runs from October 15th to December 7th. During this "Annual Enrollment Period," (AEP), you can change plans and carriers.


Sample Medicare Supplement Monthly Rates (Age 65 -- Plan A)

$82 -- Globe Life & Accident
$83 -- AARP (UnitedHealthcare)
$88 -- Omaha
$89 -- Aetna
$90 -- Central States
$92 -- State Farm
$94 -- Anthem BCBS
$94 -- Medical Mutual
$103 -- United American
$105 -- Thrivent
$107 -- Summa
$107 -- Equitable
$109 -- AultCare
$118 -- Medico
$120 -- USAA
$131 -- Gerber
$133 -- Humana


Ohio Medicare Advantage Plans


"Advantage" plans have become very popular because of their low premiums and smaller deductibles. Shown below are several options from licensed and registered companies. Of course, all available plans should be reviewed before enrollment.


Advantage Plans Without Drug Coverage


AARP MedicareComplete Essential
HumanaChoice R5826-021
MediGold Medical Only
Anthem MediBlue Access Core
Prime Time Health Plan Basic
HealthSpan Medicare Only Basic
Paramount Elite


Advantage Plans With Drug Coverage


AARP MedicareComplete Plans 1,2,3,4,5,6,7, and 8
Advantra Gold
Advantra Silver
Aetna Medicare Value Plan
Medigold Classic Preferred
Prime Time Health Plan Aultimate
UnitedHealthcare Assisted Living Plan
UnitedHealthcare Dual Complete
Aetna Medicare Select
Anthem MediBlue Access Enhanced
HealthSpan Medicare Plus 1,2,3 and 4


Additional Information:

About 60,000 applicants from here in Ohio have enrolled in the Marketplace through the end of January. These numbers are a bit lower than originally predicted, and match the lower than expected enrollments of young persons under age 35.

About 18 days remain in this year's Open Enrollment period. However, once the date expires (April 1), Buckeye residents will not necessarily have to wait until November to purchase a policy. There are several plans that can be purchased at any time throughout the year.
Temporary policies cost about 35%-75% less than conventional plans (without the subsidy), and can be kept for as long as one year. There are limitations, including a maternity exclusion, but it will provide up to $1 million of major medical coverage until you can enroll through the Marketplace again.

Ohio Open Enrollment for 2015 is less than five months away! It begins on November 15th and there will be numerous changes. Additional carriers will be offering policies (possibly Aetna and/or UnitedHealthcare) and rates are expected to only slightly increase. In specific areas, prices may actually reduce from 2014 levels. Tax subsidies will continue to reduce premiums and the noncompliance penalty for not enrolling is still in effect.

Anthem, Medical Mutual, Humana and HealthSpan are early favorites to have the most competitive pricing. As soon as the 2015 prices are posted, we'll discuss them with you.

Ohio is one of 15 states that have lowered the number of uninsured consumers. Almost 50,000 fewer persons went uncovered in 2013, according to figures from the US Census Bureau. The 2014 statistics will be available next Fall, and are expected to show a continuing trend, and possibly as many as 100,000 fewer persons without benefits.

"OneExchange," will administer the Medicare-eligible coverage for the Ohio Public Employees Program (OPERS) in 2016. About $150,000 persons and their spouses will be impacted. The change should result in a higher number of available options at a lower cost. Typically, persons enrolled in OPERS receive more than $300 per month to apply towards their medical plan selection.

2016 Ohio Marketplace rates have not been released yet. But the initial filings that were submitted last month indicate some increases are coming. We posted below several of the requests submitted by major companies.

19.56% -- UnitedHealthcare Off-Exchange Individual
17.84% -- Aetna HMO Small Group
17.29% -- HealthSpan Individual
16.99% -- Medical Mutual Individual
13.92% -- Medical Mutual Small Group
Assurant is in the process of exiting the US individual market and will not be offering policies next year. Existing Ohio customers will be able to change carriers without having to medically qualify.

Several companies are beginning to show signs that large financial losses may be looming. UnitedHealthcare, Humana, and HealthSpan are discouraging 2016 enrollments by eliminating all broker compensation for individual and family plan enrollments. Although the dollar amount involved is not substantial, it appears that a substantial amount of unanticipated claims may cost these carriers hundreds of millions of dollars.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *